Many golfers treat a broomstick putter like a common wedge, assuming they can just pick one up and start rolling in birdies. This approach usually leads to frustration because these longer implements require a specific, pendulum-style stroke.
Understanding how your body aligns with the Best Broomstick Putters makes a massive difference on the green. Keep reading to see which models offer the stability you need.
Key Takeaways
- Measure your preferred standing height carefully because even a two-inch difference in shaft length changes your entire posture.
- Select a mallet-style head if you struggle with off-center contact since these provide more forgiveness than traditional blades.
- Confirm your handedness early, as many specialty long putters are manufactured in limited configurations for left-handed golfers.
- Focus on the balance point of the grip, because heavy grips at the top of the shaft effectively act as a counterweight.
- Prioritize face technology designed to minimize skidding, ensuring the ball begins its roll immediately upon impact.
| Ultimate Stability Choice |  |
TaylorMade Spider Broomstick Putter | Extremely high stability | Forgiving on off-center hits | Consistent roll performance | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Superior Length Control | Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 2#11 48" | Precise distance control | Comfortable upright posture | Responsive face feel | View on Amazon | Read Review | |
| Balanced Reach Option | Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 2#11 46" | Highly consistent contact | Soft, muted impact sound | User friendly mallet shape | View on Amazon | Read Review | |
| Unique Stroke Geometry |  |
Bell III Face-On Long Putter | Promotes face-on posture | Relieves back strain | Distinctive alignment design | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Alignment Master Class |  |
Odyssey Square to Square Putter | Excellent face alignment | Encourages a straight stroke | Intuitive visual aid | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Essential Grip Upgrade |  |
Winn Excel Two-Piece Grip | Superior tackiness | Excellent vibration dampening | Comfortable ergonomic feel | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Iconic Stability Platform |  |
TaylorMade Spider X Putter | High forgiveness levels | Reliable visual alignment | Stable perimeter weighting | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Modern Mallet Standard |  |
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 11 | Consistent distance control | Soft, responsive feel | Versatile mallet design | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Classic Blade Alternative | Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 8 | Clean blade aesthetic | Precise distance feedback | Great for arced strokes | View on Amazon | Read Review | |
| Exceptional Value Performer | Wilson Infinite Bucktown Putter | Great value for money | Counter-balanced for stability | Anti-glare finish | View on Amazon | Read Review |
More Details on Our Top Picks
-
TaylorMade Spider Broomstick Putter
If you struggle with the yips or maintaining a consistent pendulum stroke, this putter is your best friend. The high moment of inertia design makes the head incredibly resistant to twisting on off-center hits. It acts like a heavy anchor on the green, keeping your path straight and true.
But be aware that the large head profile can look bulky if you prefer a traditional blade aesthetic. It requires a bit of an adjustment period to get used to the longer shaft length. Once you find your rhythm, the ball rolls off the face with impressive smoothness.
- Brand:TaylorMade
- Model:Spider
- Head Shape:Mallet
- Additional Feature:High moment of inertia design
- Additional Feature:Face insert for soft feel
- Additional Feature:Perimeter weighting for stability
-
Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 2#11 48"
This 48-inch option is ideal for golfers who want to keep their eyes directly over the ball without hunching over. The face milling pattern creates a crisp, responsive feel that helps you judge distance on long lag putts. It is essentially a precision tool for those who prefer the arm-lock style of putting.
The shaft length is quite specific, so you need to be sure your posture fits this tall setup. It does not offer the same adjustability as some custom builds. However, the balance point feels natural for a longer stroke.
- Brand:Cleveland Golf
- Model:Huntington Beach Soft 2#11
- Shaft Length:48 inches
- Head Shape:Mallet
- Additional Feature:Speed optimized face milling
- Additional Feature:Soft feel construction
- Additional Feature:Balanced weight distribution
-
Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 2#11 46"
Choosing the 46-inch version gives you slightly more control if the 48-inch model feels just a bit too tall for your natural arm length. It retains the same soft feel technology that makes this series a favorite for touch-based putters. You get the benefits of a long-shaft putter without feeling like you are swinging a pool cue.
Just remember that even a two-inch difference changes your setup geometry. Make sure your shoulders stay level through the stroke to maximize the alignment aids on the crown. It is a solid performer for those who want a reliable, steady stroke.
- Brand:Cleveland Golf
- Model:Huntington Beach Soft 2#11
- Shaft Length:46 inches
- Head Shape:Mallet
- Additional Feature:Diamond CNC milling pattern
- Additional Feature:Optimized center of gravity
- Additional Feature:Alignment-focused head design
-
Bell III Face-On Long Putter
This is a specialized piece of equipment for players who prefer a face-on putting style. The long, upright design allows you to stand beside the ball like you are playing croquet, which can be a lifesaver for golfers with severe back pain. It is a niche design but performs exactly as intended for that specific stance.
Because of the non-traditional shape, it will definitely draw attention on the putting green. You might find the head weight feels lighter than standard mallets, requiring a more deliberate stroke. It is a clever design for those who have exhausted traditional options.
- Brand:Bell III
- Head Shape:Mallet
- Hand Orientation:Left Hand
- Additional Feature:Non-anchor long design
- Additional Feature:Polished finish
- Additional Feature:Specialized upright lie angle
-
Odyssey Square to Square Putter
The main goal here is to keep the putter face square through the zone from start to finish. This head design effectively eliminates the arc in your stroke, which is perfect for players who fight a shaky path. It acts like a guided rail system for your ball.
You might find the visual cues take a few practice sessions to interpret correctly. It is not designed for golfers who like to manipulate the face with their hands. Stick to a smooth tempo and let the putter do the heavy lifting.
- Brand:Odyssey Golf
- Head Shape:Mallet
- Additional Feature:High contrast alignment lines
- Additional Feature:Engineered for straight paths
- Additional Feature:Consistent face response
-
Winn Excel Two-Piece Grip
Sometimes you do not need a new putter, just a better connection to your hands. This two-piece grip provides the tacky texture and vibration dampening that long-putter players crave. It is a simple way to gain better control over a long shaft without spending a fortune.
Installing a two-piece grip requires a bit of patience to ensure both parts are perfectly aligned. If you rush the process, you will feel the seam throughout your round. Take your time to get the tackiness and fit just right.
- Brand:Winn
- Grip Type:Two-piece
- Additional Feature:Moisture-resistant surface
- Additional Feature:Excel polymer material
- Additional Feature:Enhanced shot feedback
-
TaylorMade Spider X Putter
The Spider X is legendary for its weight distribution that pushes mass toward the perimeter. It is best for golfers who want a forgiving head that keeps the face square when they strike the ball off the heel or toe. The True Path alignment system is a clever way to frame the ball and keep your focus sharp.
The head is quite large, which can be a distraction if you prefer a compact blade. It also has a distinct sound at impact that some players find a bit hollow. However, the performance benefits far outweigh these minor personal preferences.
- Brand:TaylorMade
- Model:Spider X
- Head Shape:Mallet
- Additional Feature:True Path alignment system
- Additional Feature:Multi-material construction
- Additional Feature:Heavy steel frame
-
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 11
Model 11 is a fantastic choice if you want a modern mallet shape that prioritizes both distance control and accuracy. The face milling varies across the face to ensure that even slightly off-center strikes travel the same distance as center-struck ones. It is a workhorse putter that does everything well.
The head is slightly more rounded than other mallets, which might affect your visual preference for straight lines. It is a very neutral putter, meaning it won't force you into a specific stroke type. It just provides reliable feedback on every green.
- Brand:Cleveland Golf
- Model:HB Soft 2 Model 11
- Head Shape:Mallet
- Additional Feature:Speed-optimized face milling
- Additional Feature:Premium satin finish
- Additional Feature:Balanced stroke mechanics
-
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 8
If you want the benefits of the HB Soft 2 technology but prefer a traditional blade look, Model 8 is the winner. It offers a cleaner, streamlined profile that is easier to frame the ball with if you have a slight arc in your stroke. It feels more like a classic instrument in your hands.
The smaller head profile means it is slightly less forgiving than the larger mallets in the line. You need to be a bit more precise with your contact to get the best results. It is ideal for players who value feel and feedback over maximum forgiveness.
- Brand:Cleveland Golf
- Model:HB Soft 2 Model 8
- Head Shape:Blade
- Additional Feature:Speed-optimized face milling
- Additional Feature:Sleek satin finish
- Additional Feature:Refined sole geometry
-
Wilson Infinite Bucktown Putter
The Bucktown is a high-value option that packs a lot of technology into a very approachable package. The counter-balanced design helps keep your hands quiet during the stroke, which is excellent for those who struggle with wristy movements. It has a dark, anti-glare finish that looks great even in bright midday sun.
The grip is quite thick, which is great for some but might feel too chunky for others. You might also find the weight distribution a bit different from premium boutique brands. Still, it provides a solid, consistent roll that rivals much more expensive options.
- Brand:Wilson
- Model:Infinite Bucktown
- Head Shape:Mallet
- Additional Feature:Counter-balanced weighting
- Additional Feature:Dark matte finish
- Additional Feature:Large parallel alignment lines
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it legal to anchor the broomstick putter against my body?
The rules changed in 2016, so you can no longer press the grip against your chest or chin to stabilize the stroke. You must keep the club a small distance away from your body throughout the entire motion. It takes some practice, but you can still reap the benefits of the extended length without violating the rules.
Why would I choose this over a standard putter?
If you suffer from the yips or struggle to keep your wrists steady, the broomstick length acts like a pendulum stabilizer. The extra length moves the balance point higher, which makes it much harder for your hands to flick the club at the wrong moment. It is a great way to simplify your stroke when your nerves get the better of you.
How do I determine the correct length for me?
Stand in your normal putting stance and have a friend measure the distance from the center of your chest to the ground. You generally want the grip to sit 2 to 4 inches below your chin. Most stock options come in set lengths, so you may need to trim the shaft or order a custom build to get the fit perfect.
Do these putters work for every type of green?
They perform well on almost all surfaces, though they really shine on slow or bumpy greens where you need a smooth, rolling stroke. The heavy head helps the ball plow through inconsistent grass without deflecting off-line. You might find them slightly harder to manage on extremely fast greens until you adjust to the added weight.
Are they difficult to transport in a standard golf bag?
They are definitely taller than your driver, so they will stick out quite a bit from the top of your bag. You should consider using a headcover with a long sleeve to protect the extended shaft from rubbing against your irons. It is a small inconvenience for the added accuracy you gain on the green.
Jamesmathew is an expert Amazon affiliate writer, helping readers discover top products, smart deals, and practical buying guides through honest reviews and insightful content.